Massachusetts School Library Association
            MEMBER PORTAL                
​Join or Renew     Member Directory​
  • Home
  • About Us
    • MSLA Leadership 2022-23
    • Executive Board Meetings
    • Joint Statements: MLA, MassCUE
    • Spotlight Archive
    • Strategic Plan 2016-22
    • MSLA Constitution
  • Membership
    • Member Portal
    • Join or Renew Your Membership
    • Members Map
    • Email List
    • Regions >
      • Boston
      • Northeast
      • Metrowest
      • Southeast
      • Central
      • West
  • Conference
    • MSLA and PDPs
  • Resources
    • DESE Rubric
    • Certification & Licensure
    • Program Standards & Rubrics
    • Job Description: School Librarian
    • Job Listings
    • MLS Strategic Planning
    • Intellectual Freedom
  • Advocacy
    • MA School Library Study for Equity & Access
    • Everyday Advocacy
    • ESSA
    • Exemplary Programs
  • Newsletter
    • 2023 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2023
    • 2022 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2022
      • May 2022
      • October 2022
    • 2021 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2021
      • May 2021
      • October 2021
    • 2020 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2020
      • May 2020
      • October 2020
    • 2019 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2019
      • May 2019
      • October 2019
    • 2018 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2018
      • May 2018
      • October 2018
    • 2017 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2017
      • May 2017
      • September 2017
      • October 2017
    • 2016 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2016
      • May 2016
      • October 2016
    • 2015 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • April 2015
      • November 2015
    • MSLA Forum 2002-2013
  • Awards
    • Judi Paradis Memorial Grant
    • Archive: History of Awards
    • 2019 Awards Pictures
    • 2018 Awards Pictures
    • 2017 Awards Pictures
    • 2016 Awards Pictures
    • 2015 Awards Pictures
  • Bookmark Contest
    • 2023 Winners
    • 2022 Winners
    • 2020 Winners
    • 2019 and 2018 Winners
    • 2016 and 2017 Winners
    • 2012 to 2015 Winners
    • 2009 to 2011 Winners
    • 2004 to 2008 Winners
    • Bookmark Judges

Reintroducing Printed Books to the Cushing Academy Library

10/15/2016

15 Comments

 

“Isn't that the library that did away with books?”

Mark Melchior, MLIS, served as Library Director at Cushing Academy from August 2014 to July 2016.
In 2009, the head of school at Cushing Academy announced that the school’s library would remove all its printed materials and become an all-digital library ‘for the 21st century.’ In 2014, I was hired (under new leadership) and asked to rebalance the library’s offerings and restore print resources. The challenge was both intriguing and daunting. The opportunity to build a collection from the ground up was certainly appealing.  At the same time, I knew it would not be a fresh start. What might appear at first blush as a straightforward exercise in purchasing and cataloging held a much broader challenge: to rebuild damaged relationships and forge reconciliation among members of the Cushing community surprised, angered and frustrated by the changes that began in 2009. This is an account of my work to restore a print collection and the standing of the library in the school community.
I began by acquainting myself with two of the most important building blocks of any school library: the taught curriculum and the faculty.  Library materials are only as relevant as they are useful to what is being taught and experienced in the classroom. And faculty, for their part, must nurture student reading and exploration (i.e., research).  If the library is to occupy a vital place in student lives, then cooperation and collaboration in instruction is key to making a library successful.

The print purge was a traumatic event for Cushing faculty. Many faculty told me that they felt their library had been taken away from them. Restoring their trust and renewing their interest in collaborative instruction and programming was a top priority for me, and one of the most difficult (and most rewarding) parts of the work I did.

On my first morning at Cushing, I met a faculty member who was interested in the work of a popular adventure writer/historian. I mentioned that I had just heard the author speak about a new book of his. The faculty member responded, “I'd love to read that.” To which I responded, “I can get it for you. Do you want it in print or on a Kindle?” At that moment, his shoulders visibly relaxed and he said, “I wasn't even going to ask you for a copy because I knew the answer would be the Kindle --and I hate reading on the Kindle. So, yes, a print copy, please.”


Needless to say, I began purchasing print that very day. And I asked the library staff to offer the option of a printed copy anytime someone requested a title. (In the prior five years, Kindle eReaders had been the only platform for anyone seeking books from the library.)  After the first two months of school, we found that eight out of every 10 requests were for materials in printed form. Of course, the corollary is that some readers acclimated well to the Kindle device and preferred it in some instances. The point is, we as librarians work with students and faculty to give them what they want in the format they can use. This basic, long-standing expectation of library services had been overturned in an instant in 2009, and would be slow to restore.

The visuals have changed irrevocably. The library will never go back to looking as it did before the change. Tall, imposing stacks holding some 30,000 volumes will not reappear. A cafe and soft seating have displaced study carrels and ways of studying that preceded the iPhone and laptop. Low shelving units that remained on-site --empty after the change -- have be redeployed as part of the small, leaner print collection. In 2014 when I arrived, the library still held visual and performing arts books, some fiction, and a ragtag collection of donated books. At the end of the 2015-2016 academic year, the collection stood at 4500 or so print volumes.

Purchasing and displaying new materials prominently might seem to be evidence enough of a re-orientation of the library offerings -- but it’s not. Memories persist in spite of contradicting empirical evidence. A full two years after we began the restoration of the print collection, students guiding campus tours would stop in front of a large display filled with new books and describe the library as all-digital, ‘on Kindles.’

Despite the library staff’s best attempts to promote a new and expanding print collection as part of the library offerings-- through coaching tour guides, regular contact with students and faculty at library front desk, and instruction sessions in the library that showcase print and digital materials, the uptake in the community has been gradual. My assumption is that it will take a generation of students (that is, the four year cycle), and ample opportunities to work with students and faculty in the classroom in ways that demonstrate the utility of print alongside digital offerings for the restoration to be complete.

The most important parts of the school library experience are social. In some ways, the all-digital library sealed off many of the shared experiences that we as librarians rely on to encourage reading and the use of the collections. Print books, and the displays and events created for their promotion, gave us a much broader array of possible ways of connecting to students and faculty. The success of almost all our programming -- Banned Book Week, Poetry Nights, Book Club, Blind Date with a Book -- was only possible given the availability of print as a means of distribution and promotion.

Many librarians and IT staff from peer institutions have visited the Cushing library to observe the results of the digital library experiment. Although I believe that print is an important component of an school library’s offerings, I have met many who are pressed for space, and considering a dramatic consolidation of print offerings. Over time, I have developed a short list of considerations that should be addressed in the planning stages of any large-scale curtailment of print.

  1. The loss of a print collection forces some, if not many, readers into reading formats that they do not enjoy or have difficulty using. Cushing’s academic support program, for instance, found the library’s Kindles helpful for some students; others absolutely needed to read from the print page. Consider the features and limitations of digital devices as well (listening, not reading; note-taking, etc).
  2. Digital-only collections narrow the range of available content, and force teachers to seek digital alternatives and alter their course preparation and design. In these situations, the library becomes a driver of how instruction happens in an uncomfortable way by forcing workarounds in some cases.
  3. The promotion of reading, book events and reading clubs -- social elements of the library’s outreach -- are much more difficult without physical books for visual support. Consider Banned Book Week. How do you teach the pernicious effects of banning books when you have removed them from view?

Although the print collection has not yet been fully integrated into the library experience at Cushing, there are glimmers of hope that it will be. The new YA materials, for instance, are well-used and create important connections with readers. Of course, dedicated readers will find their way to the books they seek. It is the non-readers, those who read with difficulty and those who need support and encouragement that have the most to lose when a library undergoes a dramatic shift away from print collections without adequate consideration of the consequences on teaching, learning and the relationships that bind them together. Perhaps it takes a dramatic departure such as the Cushing experiment to learn what’s most important about the school library experience.
Mark served as library director at Cushing Academy from August 2014 to July 2016. He welcomes your inquiries and comments about this piece. You can reach him at m.w.melchior@gmail.com
15 Comments
Sue Doherty
10/16/2016 01:05:18 pm

This is fantastic news, and thank you so much for sharing it! Your observation about a majority of people preferring print to digital is something I've also seen, even in young people. I asked a 7th grade class earlier this year whether they preferred reading digital or print, and about 2/3 of them raised their hands for print. When I asked why, they gave reasons such as no distractions, it's easier to keep track of where you are, a feeling of accomplishment in finishing the book, and additional reasons that I've also heard from other young people over the years. And research keeps emerging that people tend to learn and comprehend more complex ideas better from print.

I shared this article on the FB ALA Thinktank and a few other places, and it's making a lot of people happy to hear this news!

Reply
Mark Melchior
10/16/2016 08:28:27 pm

Thanks for sharing this on FB/ALA Think Tank!

Reply
Sue Doherty
10/17/2016 05:54:39 am

My pleasure! People are absolutely giddy reading about this!

Marlene Sue Heroux
10/16/2016 05:25:06 pm

Thank you so much for writing and sharing your article. I commend you for taking on the challenge and the progress you've made. Your insight into the process and how to bring the library back for the campus will help many others.

Reply
CJ Miller
10/17/2016 04:11:04 pm

Pardon me if this is somehow off the wall, but what about the students? Nowhere in this article do I see anything about what students like, or want; how the recreational books will help those who need some extra input, or even how the books they like will tie in on an academic level. This strikes me as very unbalanced, almost as much as getting rid of books in the first place.

Reply
Mark Melchior
10/17/2016 04:44:16 pm

Thanks for your comment, CJ.

Students, and their library needs and interests, are our first concern. Sometimes I refer to them as simply "readers," and that may have been confusing. The library resources we provide are intended to support students in their classes and in their extra-curricular interests. We work with faculty on the coursework side; and we ask students for input on books and other materials that support their extra-curricular interests through the student book club, other student-directed library activities and events (I mention a few of them in the text: Poetry Night, Blind Date with a Book, Banned Book Week) and one-on-one conversations.

One of the points I try to make in this article is that it has been difficult to re-engage with many of the students who came to the school during the all-digital period, and "wrote off" the library even as the library ramped up print purchasing in the last two years.

I agree with you that school librarians need to be in touch with their students to meet their library needs and interests. I'm sorry if that didn't come through to you in this article.

Reply
Karen Perry
10/18/2016 08:07:29 am

"And I asked the library staff to offer the option of a printed copy anytime someone requested a title. " The option was restored to provide what was wanted and needed.

Thank you for writing about this experience. All of us in the public school section shuddered uncontrollably when the 2009 story first came out.

Reply
Clare O'Neill
10/18/2016 09:31:39 am

Mark,
The question of 'bookless' libraries has just come up on LM_Net. May I post your article there? Thank you so much for this thoughtful article. At the time Cushing went digital, I also worked part time at Borders Books, and the staff was also aghast. I shared your article on the Borders Class of 2011 FB page.

Reply
Mark melchior
10/19/2016 10:04:12 pm

Yes, of course, please share with LM_Net. And thanks.

Reply
Bonnie Barnes link
10/18/2016 09:37:07 am

Just wondering--does the school still have the same head and administrators as before?

Reply
Valerie Dube link
10/23/2016 03:46:47 pm

From the second line of the article:
"In 2014, I was hired (under new leadership) and asked to rebalance the library’s offerings and restore print resources."

Reply
Valerie Dube link
10/23/2016 03:47:11 pm

From the second line of the article:
"In 2014, I was hired (under new leadership) and asked to rebalance the library’s offerings and restore print resources."

Reply
Valerie Dube link
10/23/2016 03:48:09 pm

From the second line of the article:
"In 2014, I was hired (under new leadership) and asked to rebalance the library’s offerings and restore print resources."

Reply
Valerie Dube link
10/23/2016 03:48:23 pm

From the second line of the article:
"In 2014, I was hired (under new leadership) and asked to rebalance the library’s offerings and restore print resources."

Reply
Valerie Dube link
10/23/2016 03:48:48 pm

From the second line of the article:
"In 2014, I was hired (under new leadership) and asked to rebalance the library’s offerings and restore print resources."

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Forum Newsletter

    Co-Editors
    Reba Tierney and
    ​Luke Steere

    Reba is the School Librarian at Waltham High School; Luke is School Librarian at  Wilson Middle in Natick

    Click to set custom HTML

    Categories

    All
    AASL
    Academic
    Advocacy
    ALA
    Authors
    Book Bans
    Book Challenges
    Book Trailers
    Cataloging
    Censorship
    Column
    Conference
    Copyright
    Culture
    Databases
    Dewey
    Digital Citizenship
    E Books
    E-books
    Elementary
    ESSA
    Ethics
    Evaluation
    Graphic Books
    Graphic Novels
    Inquiry
    Leadership
    Learning Commons
    Legislation
    Literacy
    Maker Space
    Nonfiction
    Orientation
    Planning
    PLN
    President's Remarks
    Professional Development
    Reading
    Research
    Science
    Secondary
    Standards
    Technology
    Union
    Volunteers
    Weeding

    Archives

    February 2023
    October 2022
    May 2022
    February 2022
    October 2021
    May 2021
    February 2021
    October 2020
    May 2020
    February 2020
    October 2019
    May 2019
    February 2019
    October 2018
    May 2018
    February 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    May 2017
    February 2017
    October 2016
    May 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    April 2015

    MSLA Forum Past Issues:
    January 2015
    April 2015
    ​
    2002-2015 MSLA Forum
The Massachusetts School Library Association  works to ensure every school has a school library program that is fully integrated at all grade levels across the curriculum and has a significant and measurable impact on student achievement….Read more…..and Learn more about MSLA

Contact MSLA:
Emily Kristofek, Office Manager/Event Planner
P.O. Box 336. Wayland, MA 01778
ekristofek@maschoolibraries.org
​
508-276-1697 

Massachusetts School Library Association. All Rights Reserved.  Copyright 2023.