Massachusetts School Library Association
            MEMBER PORTAL                
​Join or Renew     Member Directory​
  • Home
  • About Us
    • MSLA Leadership 2022-23
    • Executive Board Meetings
    • Joint Statements: MLA, MassCUE
    • Spotlight Archive
    • Strategic Plan 2016-22
    • MSLA Constitution
  • Membership
    • Member Portal
    • Join or Renew Your Membership
    • Members Map
    • Email List
    • Regions >
      • Boston
      • Northeast
      • Metrowest
      • Southeast
      • Central
      • West
  • Conference
    • MSLA and PDPs
  • Resources
    • DESE Rubric
    • Certification & Licensure
    • Program Standards & Rubrics
    • Job Description: School Librarian
    • Job Listings
    • MLS Strategic Planning
    • Intellectual Freedom
  • Advocacy
    • MA School Library Study for Equity & Access
    • Everyday Advocacy
    • ESSA
    • Exemplary Programs
  • Newsletter
    • 2023 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2023
    • 2022 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2022
      • May 2022
      • October 2022
    • 2021 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2021
      • May 2021
      • October 2021
    • 2020 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2020
      • May 2020
      • October 2020
    • 2019 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2019
      • May 2019
      • October 2019
    • 2018 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2018
      • May 2018
      • October 2018
    • 2017 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2017
      • May 2017
      • September 2017
      • October 2017
    • 2016 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2016
      • May 2016
      • October 2016
    • 2015 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • April 2015
      • November 2015
    • MSLA Forum 2002-2013
  • Awards
    • Judi Paradis Memorial Grant
    • Archive: History of Awards
    • 2019 Awards Pictures
    • 2018 Awards Pictures
    • 2017 Awards Pictures
    • 2016 Awards Pictures
    • 2015 Awards Pictures
  • Bookmark Contest
    • 2023 Winners
    • 2022 Winners
    • 2020 Winners
    • 2019 and 2018 Winners
    • 2016 and 2017 Winners
    • 2012 to 2015 Winners
    • 2009 to 2011 Winners
    • 2004 to 2008 Winners
    • Bookmark Judges

Picture Book Column: Shining a Spotlight on Nonfiction with a Mock Sibert Election

2/14/2023

0 Comments

 
Francesca Mellin is the Head Librarian at The Pike School in Andover, MA

Picture
On Monday, January 30, I - like many of you - was glued to the live stream of the American Library Association’s Youth Media Awards, cheering along with the live audience for many of my favorites. I was also putting the final touches on the library’s transformation into an election center for a new collaborative venture, Pike’s inaugural Mock Sibert Award.

During the course of this year, I’ve been excited to re-connect with teachers to support curriculum, especially because a new built-in meeting structure with teaching teams has created consistent co-planning time.
​

The Units of Study for Teaching Reading, from the Teachers College Reading and Writing Project, is a major component of our literacy curriculum in several grades. In particular, the 4th grade nonfiction unit of study, situated in the winter term, has been an area of successful collaboration and support. Over the years, teachers have routinely brought their Language Arts classes to the library for nonfiction book talks, and have also been very receptive to incorporating Melissa Stewart’s 5 Kinds of Nonfiction framework into the unit, since it complements their instruction on writing craft moves.

When I floated the idea of piloting a Mock Sibert Award election with students this year, the 4th grade teachers were all in! They saw how it would deepen learning, and were very willing to commit classroom time to make this experience meaningful for the students.

Which Books to Choose?

Given the realities of the school schedule and the vagaries of New England winter weather, we could only examine three titles, in order that the mock voting would align as closely to the real Sibert announcement as possible. I chose illustrated texts that could be read aloud in one class period. Books also needed to be relevant and engaging to a range of 4th grade readers. I decided that students would have more success when comparing titles with a similar focus. My final choices all were science/nature oriented, but offered contrast in terms of narrative style and visual presentation.
Picture
Adapting the Sibert Criteria

I knew I needed to mirror the text feature and craft move language that LA teachers focus on in their teaching. I also wanted to write the criteria as questions, since this framework would make it easier for students to tap into their thinking. After reading the Sibert Medal criteria closely and reviewing other Mock Sibert materials, I decided on three areas, with a total of five questions. Melody Allen’s student-friendly version of the Sibert criteria, as described on Melissa Stewart’s blog, was a valuable tool in this process. Here’s the result:

Pike Mock Sibert Criteria (adapted from the Sibert criteria) When deciding if a book is distinguished, the 4th grade Mock Sibert Committee will use these guiding questions:

​CRAFT

  • Does the author use excellent and engaging language?
  • Is the visual presentation excellent and engaging?
CONTENT
  • Are the ideas and facts organized, presented clearly, and documented with a bibliography?
  • Do the text features (table of contents, index, maps, photos, timelines, etc.) enhance understanding of the facts and ideas?
CONNECTION
  • How highly does the book interest me?​
Picture
The “Three Cs” in Action

Our collaborative plan began in December with me introducing the exciting Mock Sibert process to students in our weekly library time, and teachers launching the Language Arts non-fiction unit in classrooms. Students learned about the actual award at the same time that they also visited the library with their LA classes for non-fiction book tastings. I read Antoinette Portis’ Hey, Water! aloud to introduce students to the skill of evaluating a book with our “Three Cs” criteria in mind. In the LA classrooms, instruction focused on identifying non-fiction text features and observing the choices writers and illustrators make to engage the reader.

Picture

​In January, we dove into reading our three contenders. Students heard each book twice; the second time, they wrote their observations and thoughts on a recording sheet. Each teacher found time in their schedule for me to do this second reading and recording session, and it was invaluable for students to see us co-teaching. We also held brief discussions where students shared their observations, appreciations, and questions about choices the authors and illustrators made.

Picture
Time to Vote!

​
In preparation for our Mock Sibert election, students reviewed the books and their recording sheets. After making a decision about their top choice, they wrote a paragraph explaining their reasoning. I also previewed what the ballot would look like, explaining that students would assign a rank to every contender.

Students wrote thoughtfully about their choice. “Organized and full of facts” was one student’s content-based reason for voting for Tree Hole Homes. Writing about The Universe in You, students cited the excellent craft moves of “everything getting smaller,” and the use of a repeating refrain with a “dot-dot-dot” right before each page turn. Students especially appreciated the use of photographs in Honeybee Rescue, and wrote about their strong connection to the narrative-style presentation. “I feel like I’m rooting for the bees.”

​
On the afternoon of January 30, teachers escorted their classes to the library, where I checked students in at the door (very official!) and gave them a ballot. You could have heard a pin drop as they went to their “voting booth” and picked up the provided pencil.

And the Winner Is…

Armed with a large coffee and my trusty tabulation sheet, I got to work unfolding the huge pile of ballots. As tally marks mounted, one front runner emerged, only to have a different book take its place. When all the votes were counted, three votes separated the top two books and…three students had been absent. I was scheduled to announce the winner to the entire grade the next morning! The teachers and I decided that if the students were not in school the next day, we’d cast their votes by proxy, using the information from the paragraphs they had written.

Those three votes made a huge difference. The outcome was - a tie. By the voting criteria of the real Sibert committee, we did not have a clear winner. For the students, though, the message that every vote mattered was powerful, and the announcement was met with cheers and applause.​
Picture
Was it perfect? No. Is there room for improvement? Yes. We’re already thinking about next year’s Mock Sibert experience. I’d better get reading!

Works Cited

Burns, Loree Griffin. Honeybee Rescue: A Backyard Drama. Illustrated by Ellen Harasimowicz, Charlesbridge, 2022.

Chin, Jason. The Universe in You: A Microscopic Journey. Holiday House, 2022.

Portis, Antoinette. Hey, Water! Neal Porter Books, 2019.

“Robert F. Sibert Informational Book Medal.” American Library Association. Association for Library Service to Children, a division of the American Library Association, 2015, https://www.ala.org/alsc/awardsgrants/bookmedia/sibert. Accessed 30 January 2023.

Stewart, Melissa. “5 Kinds of Nonfiction.” Melissa Stewart: Science Books and Nonfiction Teaching Resources, Melissa Stewart, 2023, https://www.melissa-stewart.com/books/teachers/bk_5_kinds_nonfiction.html. Accessed 5 January 2023.

Stewart, Melissa. “It’s Time for the Sibert Smackdown!” Celebrate Nonfiction: Exploring the Joy of Nonfiction Reading and Writing, Melissa Stewart, 17 November 2022, https://celebratescience.blogspot.com/2022/11/its-time-for-sibert-smackdown.html. Accessed 22 November 2022.

Stewart, Melissa. Tree Hole Homes: Daytime Dens and Nighttime Nooks. Illustrated by Amy Hevron, Random House, 2022.

0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Forum Newsletter

    Co-Editors
    Reba Tierney and
    ​Luke Steere

    Reba is the School Librarian at Waltham High School; Luke is School Librarian at  Wilson Middle in Natick

    Click to set custom HTML

    Categories

    All
    AASL
    Academic
    Advocacy
    ALA
    Authors
    Book Bans
    Book Challenges
    Book Trailers
    Cataloging
    Censorship
    Column
    Conference
    Copyright
    Culture
    Databases
    Dewey
    Digital Citizenship
    E Books
    E-books
    Elementary
    ESSA
    Ethics
    Evaluation
    Graphic Books
    Graphic Novels
    Inquiry
    Leadership
    Learning Commons
    Legislation
    Literacy
    Maker Space
    Nonfiction
    Orientation
    Planning
    PLN
    President's Remarks
    Professional Development
    Reading
    Research
    Science
    Secondary
    Standards
    Technology
    Union
    Volunteers
    Weeding

    Archives

    February 2023
    October 2022
    May 2022
    February 2022
    October 2021
    May 2021
    February 2021
    October 2020
    May 2020
    February 2020
    October 2019
    May 2019
    February 2019
    October 2018
    May 2018
    February 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    May 2017
    February 2017
    October 2016
    May 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    April 2015

    MSLA Forum Past Issues:
    January 2015
    April 2015
    ​
    2002-2015 MSLA Forum
The Massachusetts School Library Association  works to ensure every school has a school library program that is fully integrated at all grade levels across the curriculum and has a significant and measurable impact on student achievement….Read more…..and Learn more about MSLA

Contact MSLA:
Emily Kristofek, Office Manager/Event Planner
P.O. Box 336. Wayland, MA 01778
ekristofek@maschoolibraries.org
​
508-276-1697 

Massachusetts School Library Association. All Rights Reserved.  Copyright 2023.