Massachusetts School Library Association
            MEMBER PORTAL                
​Join or Renew     Member Directory​
  • Home
  • About Us
    • MSLA Leadership 2022-23
    • Executive Board Meetings
    • Joint Statements: MLA, MassCUE
    • Spotlight Archive
    • Strategic Plan 2016-22
    • MSLA Constitution
  • Membership
    • Member Portal
    • Join or Renew Your Membership
    • Members Map
    • Email List
    • Regions >
      • Boston
      • Northeast
      • Metrowest
      • Southeast
      • Central
      • West
  • Conference
    • MSLA and PDPs
  • Resources
    • DESE Rubric
    • Certification & Licensure
    • Program Standards & Rubrics
    • Job Description: School Librarian
    • Job Listings
    • MLS Strategic Planning
    • Intellectual Freedom
  • Advocacy
    • MA School Library Study for Equity & Access
    • Everyday Advocacy
    • ESSA
    • Exemplary Programs
  • Newsletter
    • 2023 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2023
    • 2022 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2022
      • May 2022
      • October 2022
    • 2021 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2021
      • May 2021
      • October 2021
    • 2020 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2020
      • May 2020
      • October 2020
    • 2019 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2019
      • May 2019
      • October 2019
    • 2018 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2018
      • May 2018
      • October 2018
    • 2017 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2017
      • May 2017
      • September 2017
      • October 2017
    • 2016 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • February 2016
      • May 2016
      • October 2016
    • 2015 MSLA Forum Issues >
      • April 2015
      • November 2015
    • MSLA Forum 2002-2013
  • Awards
    • Judi Paradis Memorial Grant
    • Archive: History of Awards
    • 2019 Awards Pictures
    • 2018 Awards Pictures
    • 2017 Awards Pictures
    • 2016 Awards Pictures
    • 2015 Awards Pictures
  • Bookmark Contest
    • 2023 Winners
    • 2022 Winners
    • 2020 Winners
    • 2019 and 2018 Winners
    • 2016 and 2017 Winners
    • 2012 to 2015 Winners
    • 2009 to 2011 Winners
    • 2004 to 2008 Winners
    • Bookmark Judges

Advice Column: Ask a Library Legend

2/15/2017

0 Comments

 
Valerie Diggs is the Librarian at Lowell Catholic High School
Questions may be submitted for this column using the confidential link at the bottom of this post
Question Number One:
"Graphic novel cataloging wisdom needed - I've inherited a rather mixed collection including GN fiction, non-fiction, and Manga all inconsistently labeled making some items almost impossible for a student to locate.'

Students, in my many years of experience, do not want to spend any great amount of time looking for what they really want to find. Using this concept as the basis for my shelving decisions, I shelved graphic novel fiction separately by author. If you are ordering books pre-processed, you can ask to have your graphic novels cataloged as fiction, so the book Anya's Ghost would be cataloged as F or FIC SAT. If you have an existing collection of GN fiction, then this would require you to change the call numbers from 741.5 to F or FIC. This can be done using a “batch” processing option in many automation systems. Of course, you then need to print new labels, but the effort is worth the extra work and the new labels can be applied by students or parent volunteers.

As for graphic novel non-fiction, this is more complicated. I generally shelved those items separately, but in my graphic novel section. So first came the graphic novel fiction arranged by author, and then the non-fiction arranged by call number. Only if I knew a certain book was curriculum-related and used alongside other non-fiction books on the topic would I shelve the non-fiction graphic novel in with the regular non-fiction. For most non-fiction graphic novels I used a location code in my automation system and also added “GN” to the spine label, above the call number. This would ensure that the books were shelved in the right location.

As for Manga, this is tricky. I finally decided to shelve the Manga by series and then by title or number in the series, depending on how the series was labeled. TI also kept Manga in my graphic novel section. ​

Question Number Two
"What do you do with books that have won the Caldecott or Newbery awards but may have some outdated/inappropriate material?  Keep them or weed?  For example, Sylvester and the Magic Pebble uses the statement 'stone-dumb,' and police are pigs (don't know if that was intentional or not, but it was written in 1969). Thank you for your thoughts."

​Weeding books can be a very school-specific and even librarian-specific process. However, this issue of whether or not Sylvester and the Magic Pebble should be kept on the shelves dates back to a 1971 column in the professional journal American Libraries titled “On Note.” This article stated the following about this book:
     ALA's Office for Intellectual Freedom has issued an advisory statement con­cerning Sylvester and the Magic Pebble:
     (1) The Library Bill of Rights, the American Library Association's basic policy statement concerning intellectual
          freedom, states that, "... no library materials should be proscribed or re­moved from libraries because of partisan or
          doctrinal  disapproval."

     (2) Librarians who remove Sylvester and the Magic Pebble from their col­lections, or who remove the controver­sial
           page, play, in effect, the role of censor. Such a role violates both the spirit and the letter of the Library Bill of
           Rights.

     (3) In  the absence of a court order, issued after a fair hearing and deci­sion, the publication Sylvester and the Magic
           Pebble
is a legitimate library acquisition, fully protected under the law.


In the text of the advisory  state­ment, the OIF stated that individual libraries have responded to  requests for removal of the book in  varying ways and one librarian went  so far as to tear out the controversial page and return the book to the shelf. The basis for objection is an illustration in the book depicting policemen as  pigs.
“Of Note.” American Libraries, vol. 2, no. 4, 1971, pp. 331–338. www.jstor.org/stable/25618241.
And later, an article in Children & Libraries published in 2013 states the following about the book:

     Could a simple story, Sylvester and the Magic Pebble by William Steig, about a donkey who finds a magic pebble and
     turns himself into a rock be offensive? In 1970, police in Rochester, New York, thought so because one page depicts
     the police officer as a pig. Never mind that Steig liked pigs, the book was caught up in the unrest during the Chicago
     riots when calling policemen “pigs” was a contemptuous slur. Copies of the book across the country disappeared as
     police associations made their dissatisfaction known. Sylvester survived and is happily back on library shelves today.


Cummins, Julie. "The Gold Rush." Children & Libraries: The Journal Of The Association For Library Service To Children 11.1
     (2013): 3-5.
Library & Information Science Source. Web. 24 Jan. 2017.


Lastly, as this question evokes much thought and collection development dilemma, I turned to an expert in the field. Through Helen Adams, Megan Schliesman of the Cooperative Children’s Book Center at the University of Wisconsin was contacted and asked for HER opinion. Her response:

     I don’t believe there is a blanket way to address this. Instead, I think the books have to be assessed individually, as the
     reasons they may be considered problematic may differ from book to book.  “Stone-dumb,” for example, is, I think,
     (potentially) very different from a book that has been criticized by for racism or harmful stereotypes or
     misrepresentation, such as Gerald McDermott’s Arrow to the Sun. Even then, I think you have to decide book by
     book, in the same way you would (or should) when purchasing new books, and I think the goal is informed choice.
     Regarding historical value, it depends on the point or purpose of the collection. I would question whether an
     elementary school library, for example, necessarily needs to keep old, potentially outdated books, even award
     winners, unless studying those awards are part of the curriculum in some way.


     Award books may become dated, but my opinion is to retain these award-winning books on our shelves and use
     them as springboards for healthy discussion. I have always been someone who bristles at any hint of censorship. In
     our quest to do the right thing, and with some titles, weeding can cross the line between removal of outdated
     material and censorship.


More about Megan Schliesman’s on the Cooperative Children’s Book Center’s website:  

http://ccbc.education.wisc.edu/authors/experts/schliesman.asp

So the Library Legend turned to the experts for support and reinforcement. Censorship comes in all forms. Make informed decisions for your student population and school culture is the key. There really is no “one-size-fits-all” answer to this question.

0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Forum Newsletter

    Co-Editors
    Reba Tierney and
    ​Luke Steere

    Reba is the School Librarian at Waltham High School; Luke is School Librarian at  Wilson Middle in Natick

    Click to set custom HTML

    Categories

    All
    AASL
    Academic
    Advocacy
    ALA
    Authors
    Book Bans
    Book Challenges
    Book Trailers
    Cataloging
    Censorship
    Column
    Conference
    Copyright
    Culture
    Databases
    Dewey
    Digital Citizenship
    E Books
    E-books
    Elementary
    ESSA
    Ethics
    Evaluation
    Graphic Books
    Graphic Novels
    Inquiry
    Leadership
    Learning Commons
    Legislation
    Literacy
    Maker Space
    Nonfiction
    Orientation
    Planning
    PLN
    President's Remarks
    Professional Development
    Reading
    Research
    Science
    Secondary
    Standards
    Technology
    Union
    Volunteers
    Weeding

    Archives

    February 2023
    October 2022
    May 2022
    February 2022
    October 2021
    May 2021
    February 2021
    October 2020
    May 2020
    February 2020
    October 2019
    May 2019
    February 2019
    October 2018
    May 2018
    February 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    May 2017
    February 2017
    October 2016
    May 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    April 2015

    MSLA Forum Past Issues:
    January 2015
    April 2015
    ​
    2002-2015 MSLA Forum
The Massachusetts School Library Association  works to ensure every school has a school library program that is fully integrated at all grade levels across the curriculum and has a significant and measurable impact on student achievement….Read more…..and Learn more about MSLA

Contact MSLA:
Emily Kristofek, Office Manager/Event Planner
P.O. Box 336. Wayland, MA 01778
ekristofek@maschoolibraries.org
​
508-276-1697 

Massachusetts School Library Association. All Rights Reserved.  Copyright 2023.